Living the Dream.





Showing posts with label Scott McLaren. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scott McLaren. Show all posts

Saturday, September 3, 2011

re: "War Crime! Taliban: Yes, We Murdered Brit. Scott McLaren (bumped)"

Rusty Shackleford, Ph.D. at The Jawa Report ("Sand people, get it?") enjoys moral clarity.

Money quote(s):


"Can you imagine the reaction from the European and American Left had this been a Taliban insurgent who was murdered at the hands of our soldiers? Not only would there be widespread protest, but our military would do the right thing and treat those responsible as criminals." (Emphasis in original text. - CAA.)


Our "right thing" and their (the Taliban's) "right thing" are two different.... things. Ours is based on a centuries of law of warfare which had quite different aims than that based on the koran.


"(T)here is a difference between us and them. We're the good guys. They are simply evil." (Emphasis in original text. - CAA.)


&


"They captured him alive and murdered him in cold blood.


I get the arguments for abandoning Afghanistan based on the notion that the country and its people are just so backwards that there is nothing that really can be done. I also get the argument that if we don't send at least another 100k troops more than Obama's "surge" then there's really no point. I think these are legitimate arguments."